Which Xbox 360 game is better?

-Should I get Mafia 2 or Grand Theft Auto 4?

Which one has a better story?

Which one has better gameplay?

Which one has a longer story mode?

Which one has a better sandbox/open world?

BEST ANSWERS GETS 10 POINTS!I like GTA IV more than Mafia 2.

GTA IV has a interesting story mode you get to meet many colorful characters.

The pedestrians in the GTA IV game are funny to mess around with.

The GTA IV story mode will take several hours to fully complete if you are not speeding through the game.

After the game is over you should have nice cars and cheat codes just add to the fun.

GTA IV also has add-ons that are fun and add a couple hours of game play.Mafia 2 have a better story

Mafia 2 have a better gameplay

GTA4 story mode is longer

Mafia 2 and GTA4 have a similar open world,the only thing you can do is to buy clothes,eat something and buy guns,in both you can kill the guy if you don't want to pay for guns and clothes:)